No Substitute for Reading

    25 September 2025

    In recent years, fewer boys are studying English at A level. Once more popular than maths, English now falls behind psychology, biology, and chemistry. At Truman and Tring, we believe it is important to understand why this is happening — and what it means for literacy and communication.

    Only 12,000 boys sat English A level in 2025, compared with 27,000 in 2009. Girls are studying it less too, dropping from 59,000 to 42,000 in the same period. Anne Trethewey, executive director at the exam board AQA, says increased screen time is a major factor. Children aged eight to eighteen are reading less for pleasure than at any time in the last 20 years. Only a third of children enjoy books outside school, and for boys, this falls to just a quarter.

    Trethewey explains: "That drop-off in reading for pleasure naturally leads to a lack of desire to study a subject later on. If that's happening disproportionately with secondary-age boys, they are less likely to take English Literature at A level."

    Smartphones, tablets, and changing viewing habits have a huge impact. One English teacher at a co-educational independent school in the UK, who wished to remain anonymous, said: "Attention spans, tolerance for boredom or challenge, empathy development, vocabulary — it's all affected. Reading a novel is incredibly difficult if you're used to the instant gratification of TikTok or YouTube shorts. Subjects like English are where these effects show up the most. It's not a subject where shortcuts work."

    The Problem with the GCSE Syllabus

    Another challenge is the "soulless GCSE syllabus." While exam boards can choose some texts, government rules dictate much of the content. GCSE English Literature must include a Shakespeare play, poetry from 1789 onwards (including the Romantics), a 19th-century novel, and fiction or drama from the British Isles since 1914.

    This rigid structure leaves little room for modern literature that could engage today's students. The lack of flexibility makes it harder to spark a passion for reading — especially for boys, who are already less engaged.

    At Truman and Tring, we believe students should explore contemporary authors like Hilary Mantel, Ian McEwan, Anne Tyler, William Boyd, Colm Tóibín, or Yiyun Li. Including modern crime novels, poetry, and drama could give students a reason to enjoy reading and discover the joy of literature.

    Why Reading Matters Beyond Exams

    Reading offers benefits far beyond exams. It develops empathy, critical thinking, and vocabulary — all vital for future academic and professional success. Reading helps students express ideas clearly and understand complex concepts, boosting confidence in both writing and speaking.

    Yet boys, increasingly distracted by screens, are missing out. While STEM subjects dominate headlines, literacy remains just as important. As one teacher said, "There's no point excelling at STEM subjects if you can't explain their value to your future employer."

    In a town like Tring, where education standards are high, encouraging reading for pleasure is crucial. Parents, teachers, and schools need to work together to create an environment where books are valued — not just for exams, but for lifelong learning and enjoyment.

    A Call for Change

    Modernising the English syllabus could be a first step. Giving teachers more freedom to select texts that resonate with students could reignite interest in reading. Books that reflect contemporary life, diverse perspectives, and engaging stories can help students connect with literature.

    Schools and parents can also promote reading by setting aside dedicated reading times, running book clubs, or celebrating storytelling. For boys, connecting literature to personal interests — such as sports, science fiction, or current events — can make reading exciting rather than a chore.

    At Truman and Tring, we support initiatives that encourage reading for pleasure. From recommending engaging books to highlighting the importance of literacy in everyday life, we aim to help students develop skills that last a lifetime.

    Conclusion

    The decline in boys studying English A level is more than a statistic — it shows that reading for pleasure is at risk. With the right support, updated syllabuses, and encouragement, this trend can be reversed. Reading is not just about exams; it helps students understand the world, express ideas, and enjoy stories that enrich their lives.

    In Tring and beyond, there is no substitute for reading. By giving young people the tools and freedom to read, we can ensure literacy and a love of literature remain central to education for generations to come.

    For more on the value of broad education, read our views on why we should protect English literature and how personalised learning in independent schools can nurture each student's strengths.

    Need Expert Education Advice?

    Our consultants are ready to help with school placement, admissions, tutoring and more.