Perhaps the least surprising educational news of the week is the Government announcement that it is to end funding the International Baccalaureate (IB) in state schools. Given the extra cost of teaching the IB, especially when done alongside A Levels, it's perhaps surprising that this hasn't happened before.
State schools shouldn't be unduly fazed by this news, however. The A Level has increased its status in recent years particularly with the inclusion of the extended essay and the ability for brighter pupils to stretch their talents over four subjects.
For independent schools, this is another opportunity for those offering the IB to promote their point of difference. But make no mistake, even private schools running both A Levels and the IB have found the going tough and, invariably, put a lot of pressure on pupils to choose one or the other, usually with a bias towards the IB, stressing its international dimension and reputation.
Not all is as it seems, however. Independent schools who've opted for the IB only, have often had to row back even to the extent of becoming co-ed in the sixth form to stem the departures after GCSE. And then, in one case in south-west London, re-introducing A Levels as well as announcing a ten-year plan to go fully co-ed.
Simply put, the IB curriculum does not suit everyone. It's very much for the allrounder, or less kindly put, those who don't have a passion for any one subject. The maths devotee can do double Maths at A Level but not at IB, the linguist cannot attempt several languages and so on.
What's more, universities in some cases have trouble understanding the IB and making allowances for the breadth of learning involved versus the more doubled down specialisation of A Levels. Students interviewing for scholarships find that A Level students enjoy more hours of tuition in the subject being interviewed for, than they managed at IB.
Also, some of the wider educational benefits offered by the IB can be overstated. The devotion to public service can be achieved taking the matron's dog for a walk, for example, as happens regularly at one home counties boarding school. The fact that state schools can concentrate on A Levels is no bad thing. It's arguably a better route to the preparation for study that comes with a university degree and is well understood and liked by universities. And private schools have one more opportunity to crow about their enhanced educational offering.
Good news all round.
For families weighing up A Levels versus the IB, our exam preparation service supports students through either pathway. See also our guide on why curriculum breadth matters in choosing an independent school.
