Back in the Blairite era, some would have answered this question with the unequivocal 'former polytechnics'. But that answer represents educational snobbery at its worst. The former polytechnics embraced their university status, but the best ones didn't change their spots. They kept their focus firmly on vocational courses rather than trying to compete with their more academic heritage university cousins. Witness the symbiotic relationship between Oxford Brookes and its illustrious neighbour.
No, the answer to the question posed above is a little more complex. While some former polytechnics have embraced their new status and delivered a range of courses that have cemented their status, many have not. Worst of all, some have tried to be all things to all people and failed dismally, aping the academic courses of established universities leading employers, in particular, to question their worth. Many of these will fold or radically downsize their course offering as to render them very poor relations, to be avoided by students looking for value for money and a rewarding undergraduate experience.
But the financial problem doesn't end there. Only recently Cardiff University announced redundancies in its flagship School of Mathematics, rolling it in with Data Science and Computer Technology, together with up to 400 redundancies across the board. You might well ask how a Russell Group university of some standing finds itself in this position, and there may be deeper underlying reasons. Nevertheless, this situation should alert education consultants to exercise increasing vigilance over their university recommendations. And for universities to be more transparent about their funding and future course strategy.
Make no mistake, there are even more challenging times ahead.
For families weighing up university options, our university pathways service provides carefully researched guidance based on real institutional knowledge. See also our thoughts on how to use university league tables effectively.
Truman and Tring — March 2025
